The Condorcet Efficiency Advantage that Voter Indifference Gives to Approval Voting Over Some Other Voting Rules

Abstract : Approval Voting is known to possess many good properties when voters have dichotomous preferences. But, when attention was restricted to the limiting case for large electorates with three candidates in an early study, Approval Voting was found to have the same Condorcet Efficiency as both Plurality Rule and Negative Plurality rule when no voter indifference is allowed in voters’ preferences with the assumption of the impartial culture condition (IC). However, a later study by Diss et al. (Handbook on approval voting, 2010) shows that the introduction of any degree of indifference in an extended impartial culture condition leads to a dominance of Approval Voting over both Plurality Rule and Negative Plurality Rule on the basis of Condorcet Efficiency. Scenarios were also found for which Approval Voting had greater Condorcet Efficiency than Borda Rule. The assumptions of that study are analyzed here, and an arguably more reasonable set of assumptions leads to the conclusion that Borda Rule will dominate Approval Voting on the basis of Condorcet Efficiency for all degrees of voter indifference, except for the case of completely dichotomous preferences. The same outcome is found to result in the current study for an extended version of the Impartial Anonymous Culture Condition.
Type de document :
Article dans une revue
Group Decision and Negotiation, INFORMS, 2014, 24 (2), pp.243--269. 〈10.1007/s10726-014-9388-4〉
Liste complète des métadonnées

http://hal.univ-reunion.fr/hal-01450834
Contributeur : Réunion Univ <>
Soumis le : mardi 31 janvier 2017 - 13:57:54
Dernière modification le : vendredi 14 septembre 2018 - 08:14:52

Identifiants

Collections

Citation

William V. Gehrlein, Dominique Lepelley. The Condorcet Efficiency Advantage that Voter Indifference Gives to Approval Voting Over Some Other Voting Rules. Group Decision and Negotiation, INFORMS, 2014, 24 (2), pp.243--269. 〈10.1007/s10726-014-9388-4〉. 〈hal-01450834〉

Partager

Métriques

Consultations de la notice

61